With no more fairs, fests, or presentations scheduled during the holiday season, it’s time to evaluate what we tried this year for getting books into the hands of readers. Today, let’s talk about gift-wrapped books.
You have probably seen “blind date with a book” packages at your local library or bookstore. Most often, they are wrapped in plain brown paper to preserve the mystery of the book. There might be clues written or drawn on the outside, or maybe a label indicating the kind of reader that would find the book interesting.
If you go online and type in “gift-wrapped book,” you will find a zillion photos, including instructions for fancy ways to wrap books and gorgeous pre-wrapped books with fancy prices. Etsy, no surprise, has a seemingly endless supply of them, ranging in price from $9.99 to $39.99.
They do look stunning, so earlier in the year, I decided to experiment with pre-wrapped books at in-person events like fairs and fests.
I wrapped up a selection from all my books: Agatha Annotated, Ruth by Lake and Prairie, Six Degrees of Abraham Lincoln, Haunted by History, and Book Rookie. Some were plainly wrapped, in the style of “blind date with a book.” I also bundled Ruth by Lake and Prairie with the accompanying activity book. Finally, I did my creative best in wrapping Agatha Annotated and Ruth by Lake and Prairie with fun extras. Agatha featured a couple of Poirot magnets, an English tea bag, and a fancy bookmark. Ruth included a buzz saw yo-yo, a wooden ornament, and a home-spun bookmark.
At many of the fairs we attended this year, we were tight on space, so it was tricky to show off these special offerings along with the usual display, but we managed. People did stop and look at them, even complimenting me on the wrapping, but sales didn’t follow. I tried several different price points, changed the sales message, and followed all of the usual marketing advice. And yet, people preferred to buy the unwrapped books.
It’s perplexing. Maybe in-person events are not the right venue. I could try offering pre-wrapped books online, but of course I’d have to bump the price up to handle shipping. Not to mention I’d have to do the packaging and shipping, too! We have done our own shipping, back in the early days before KDP, but that was long ago.
If you are an author who has provided pre-wrapped books successfully, I’d love to hear your thoughts. I would also love to hear your thoughts if you are a reader! Would you buy a wrapped book to surprise a friend? For yourself? Do the little related add-ons make the gift more appealing? How much extra would you pay for gift-wrapping service?
We’ll be busy with holiday marketing for the next month and a half, but any opinions would be useful as we evaluate 2026 and prepare for 2027. Thanks for your help!